Soft House Prices or Unrealistic Vendors?
There’s been a bit of discussion in recent months about a softening housing market around Australia but I wonder how much of it is more indicative of unrealistic expectations on behalf of sellers? In futures work we think in terms of Assumptions and Expectations and aim to test our understanding and so I offer this isolated example of the housing market in action for you to think about whether ‘softening’ prices are a reality. Around three years ago a two bedroom brick veneer house in Cummins Rd, East Brighton sold for approximately $440,000, which was pretty much market value at the time. The new owners subdivided the land and about a year ago built a three bedroom townhouse of a pretty high standard on the rear of the property. The style of house is likely to be attractive to a more limited market and there’s no outside space to speak of. So what would you say would be a fair price to expect at auction?
Potential bidders were pretty clear. The Real Estate Agent (Buxtons) did a great job at talking the property up and highlighted everything that was good about the property. But I wondered if the agent knew he was flogging a dead horse so to speak because he asked for an opening bid of $800,000 and eventually kicked the auction off with a vendor’s bid of $700,000. When no further bidding emerged he placed another vendor’s bid at $750,000 and the property was passed in.
Now I’m not too sure what pricing strategy the vendor had. I know that the vendor has also done a fair bit of work in the front property in which they live and I wondered if their price was based on not only what they paid for the original property, and what they spent building the subdivision, but also was an attempt to recoup money spent on their own home? But for me, having paid $440,000 three years ago and having spent perhaps another $200,000 or so adding a sub-division property out the back, expecting what is believed to have been a sale price of well over $800,000 seems an example of unrealistic expectations.
Right now entire single block double story dwellings a few years old are selling in the area for about $850,000. Some would say that even in a warm housing market, a realistic and fair price for the new Cummins Rd dwelling out the back is closer to the $600,000 mark. I’m sure you know of similar examples around Australia and beyond. When we consider real estate as an indicator of social and economic health, we need to be careful about placing too much emphasis on auction outcomes, unless we also consider how realistic the expectations for sale prices also are. And that perhaps something for lenders to also consider
Great to see some quality collaboration between the City of Casey and City of Greater Dandenong aimed at addressing or tackling Social Issues and importantly bridging the divide between ‘our area’ and ‘their area’ artificial boundaries. Well done to both Councils Here’s the oveview of what they’re doing. This one looks to be an…
Read More >Most people who’ve been involved in planning and strategy development will have heard of VUCA – Volatile, Uncertain, Complex, Ambiguous. Emerging out of the US War College in 1987, it’s come to be more widely used by consultancies aiming to at least ‘sound smart’. But that’s not the main problem with its usage Instead…
Read More >In short – ‘No’. In days of yore manufacturing data meant jobs being done, employed people being paid, sales being made. But with robotics and off-shoring in many parts of Australian manufacturing, it’s no longer the value indicator it once was. In the US it is an even less reliable indicator because in the…
Read More >I’ve writen a fair bit over the years about the need to move futures thinking out of a theoretical approach and into a more applied model. Recently I’ve come off a 6 month project working with the Asian Productivity Organisation, an entity that brings together 20 member countries and their core government policy…
Read More >Every where we look we are being given clear signs of the blatant stupidity and arguably outright criminality of a toxic system of decision making. The Menindee Lakes and Darling River disaster is one example A couple of years ago I was invited to speak at a Private Equity conference at a lovely resort…
Read More >Every year I aim to identify what I think a major focus of the upcoming year will be and in that light I’m declaring 2019 the International Year of the Cooperative. I’m prompted by a multitude of signals that my daily research has uncovered, many of which will be familiar to you – Cost of…
Read More >Here we are with the last posting of the year looking at the potential for wide ranging strategy for a country like the United States. Arguably the United States is undergoing its own version of #Brexit though without the vote of the people. Instead the dictatorial nature of what I see as an incompetent strategic…
Read More >I’m reluctant to make predictions but am getting a few calls so: My tip is on a March 2019 election – the 9th or 16th But that will be an attempt to protect the existing NSW Government hoping that voters will have sufficiently vented. That said though, it also required a Federal Minoroty Government to…
Read More >The Asian Productivity Organisation has shifted gears from being a centre for member countries to talk about productivity, to one that now wants to upskills its member countries. We’ve just completed the first chunk of helping National Productivity secretariats to ready their staff for a more proactive, future facing approach to their Country’s development …
Read More >The question is, ‘how does the thinking inside this document stack up?’ Turns out, pretty good. What we spotted and what problems we said we’d have to watch out for, are just about spot on When it was discovered that the then Prime Minister Kevin Rudd was going to hold the Australia 2020 Summit,…
Read More >