Men, What Will Your Legacy Be?

I’m male. You may like to take that into consideration with the rest of what you read as, a) I’m part of the problem b) Whatever I say cannot, no matter how well intentioned, be in anyway able to represent women

 

 

I’m prompted to write this particular piece following on from the ABC’s QandA session that aimed to look at the issue of Domestic Violence in Australia, and the many articles that have appeared today following that broadcast.  I acknowledge that men can also be victims of domestic violence at the hands of a female partner and like all victims of abuse, need support. And the overwhelming number of victims both male and female, are victims of male violence in all its forms.

I didn’t know that there was going to be a show looking at the issue of Domestic Violence until a person I follow on Twitter alerted me to the make up of the panelists. It became clear, as I’d suggest has been QandA’s bent since its inception, that once again the male voices were positioned to dominate the discussion and the threat of Mansplaining loomed darkly. I risk the same problem here though aim this at men, not women.

QandA has for the most part, been a vehicle for getting otherwise reluctant politicians (and a handful too passionately non-reluctant) to blab on relentlessly on topics for which their understanding is ideologically tainted. These shows are less ‘hypotheticals’ than they are moderated you said-you said finger pointing debates without any of the humour seen during the comedy festival. Without any chance of argument, by far QandA’s best shows are sans politicians and sans wolves in politician’s clothing. Alas those offerings are few and far between.

Which brings me to last night’s program, sans politicians (though one previous one) in which a victim of domestic violence Rosie Batty, mother of murdered son Luke was perhaps the main focal point, supported by Natasha Stott Despoja and then four other men. You can watch the program here if you missed it http://www.abc.net.au/tv/qanda/txt/s4173309.htm

I’ll not say too much about the program other than in a strong break from tradition, a male’s opinion wasn’t called for for at least 9minutes into the program with the first two questions coming from women and both female panelists being given the floor. I’m not being tongue in cheek nor flippant here – the male dominated bias of all previous panels and airtime given to male speakers on QandA is significant. In the previous two shows, one male radio broadcaster was given virtual free reign to espouse personal views, whilst in the following week, another (politician) was deemed as having a more important opinion than anyone else. It’s an issue rarely faced when Jenny Brockie does her usual excellent role at hosting Insight on the SBS

The pre QandA social media storm raged against the makeup of the panel. Whilst I didn’t disagree with that sentiment, I felt that it distracted from the conversations we could have been having. The social media (and some mainstream media) have also discussed the show, as has social media since its broadcast last night. Watching both my twitter feed and the show at the same time is always enlightening. The proposed alternative hashtag #UnSaidQandA could have come to the fore but sat in the background for just a few tweeters. But so many pertinent questions were asked that the show was not really able to deal with and I put that mainly down to the show’s format. It’s a topic that would never be taken up on commerical TV and really the only other place where even part justice to the topic might emerge on a TV show is the aforementioned Insight on SBS.

Given that overview then, some key questions that emerged and remain unanswered are

  1. Why do men choose violence?
  2. Why it is a woman’s responsibility to leave?
  3. Why can we so comprehensively respond to a pink batts program or a seige at a chocolate shop and yet choose to take no national action on an issue that leads to on average, one woman’s death PER WEEK?
  4. How can politicians say they care about this issue whilst slashing the already threadbare funding to victims of domestic violence support agencies?
  5. Why is it that somehow we condone a man using violence because he feels ashamed or powerless? That some how that emotional state justifies his actions?
  6. I’d like everyone to acknoweldge that the statistics only deal with reported cases. It is highly likely that in the instances where a woman is murdered by their partner or ex partner, many incidences of abuse went unreported.

 

So men I ask you, what will your legacy be?

To men who resort to violence to get your own way, do you think your children don’t realise you coerced their mothers with threats against her children?

Because that’s your legacy

To men who resort to violence, do you think that your kids won’t remember the cigarette burns, the welts from the horse whip, the petrol in their eyes, the windows being smashed, the screaming, the threats?

Because that’s your legacy

To men who think they have the right to control, to demean, to diminish another human being because that’s how things are or should be, where does the right come from and where does that take us?

Because that will be your legacy.

To men who think it is okay to cat call, to leer, to comment, to grope, to assault or harass someone walking home, sitting by themselves, or with their kids, or on their bikes, or on public transport, like the thousands of portrayals seen everyday on sites like EverydaySexism.co.uk in what mindset do you think your needs to act this way over-ride someone else’s right to personal safety?

Because that is your legacy

Sure maybe you’re not the violent type and might feel you have no part to play to fix this predominantly male problem. Maybe you feel it’s a cultural thing, or a drugs thing or an alcohol thing, or you might think its a physical violence thing or a court’s thing. Or it’s a poor thing or an indigenous thing or a divorced family thing or… some other ‘thing’ but not your ‘thing’ right? But if you stay silent, if you do not actively assist in the breakdown of this disgraceful behaviour, then that too defines a view of the world

And that view is one where you feel that not everyone has the right to live safely, freely and equally

And if you do nothing then sadly, that legacy, is your thing

Embracing the Hybrid Workspace – are You there yet?

Nov 15, 2023

I flag my bias towards the need for a vastly improved approach to managing staff in the work environments. V A S T L Y improved. I’m still surprised at how clunky, disorganised or naive some senior managers are when it comes to that part of the business that considers ‘people’. And rather than cover…

Read More >

Exploring Strategy Development – the Organisational Evolution model

Oct 17, 2023

An interesting public workshop in Perth in the first week of October introducing a varied group to the Organisational Evolution model. The Org-Ev is the model I developed for the start up of The Australian Strategic Planning Institute in conjunction with Steven Bowman. Given the diversity of the group, there were a number of surprises…

Read More >

Perth workshop 5th October almost fully booked

Sep 18, 2023

A note for those of you in Perth that there are just 4 spaces left for the Introduction to the Organisational Evolution Model workshop at Adina Apartments in Perth.  The Org Ev model has been designed to enhance Strategic Planning and decision making and this introductory workshop is aimed at those looking to attend the…

Read More >

Delving into Heatwave Scenarios

Sep 12, 2023

Later this month I’ll be facilitating a scenario session looking at the potential impact of a long standing heatwave event for the City of Greater Dandenong here in Australia. Heatwaves kill more people than any other weather event. By a long way. Importantly they also have a ‘fat tail’ with physical impairments to individuals often…

Read More >

Introduction to the Organisational Evolution Model workshop in Perth

Sep 9, 2023

Looking Up Feeling Good will be running an workshop on the Organisational Evolution Model in Perth. The Org-Ev model has been used by a wide number of agencies across almost all industry sectors, and was originally developed for the Australian Strategic Planning Institute. The workshop is limited to 25 people and will take place at…

Read More >

Sponsoring Vic 55 2s Master’s Hockey

Aug 21, 2023

Looking Up Feeling Good are delighted to be associated with the Victorian over 55 2s at the National Masters Championship coming up in Perth in a few month’s time across September and October. We wish all players well

Read More >

Why You Need to Read ‘Invisible Women’ Now

Aug 20, 2023

If you’re involved with setting policy, allocating funding, designing products or services and delivering on them, then one book you simply must have read is the absolutely astounding ‘Invisible Women’ by Caroline Criado Perez. What Perez has done with this book is ALL OF THE RESEARCH you need to have available to you when you…

Read More >

Preparing for Heat Waves In a World Primed to Cook

Aug 12, 2023

Are we there yet? Have people finally cottoned on to the idea that maybe, things aren’t going so well for the planet and our place in it? Storms, up; floods, up; fires, up; droughts, up; people being displaced by climate events, up.  The signals are all around us. And yet, as a species we struggle…

Read More >

Strategic Impact of Long Term Decision Making

Jul 18, 2023

One of the most challenges aspects for owners of businesses, and also for Boards charged with running businesses, is how to allow for the impact of a decision to unfold over time.  Many listed company Boards will be delaying with a CEO on a limited tenure. The Board will have set expectations for performance and…

Read More >

Emerging Risks for Australian LGAs

Jun 8, 2023

Local Governments in Australia face an emerging risk space that many seem unaware of. Brought on by rising costs, especially in business premises rentals, compliance needs and registration costs, research we’ve identified as part of work with a Local Government client is indicating a significant increase in businesses popping up in residential areas. What seems…

Read More >