Strategic Futurists; Value Systems Specialists

Events

Pixar's Wall E gives us a glimpse - but is it too cute to hit the mark?

Monday 29 September 2008

I sat in the theatre with my two young children over the weekend watching Pixar's latest animation film 'Wall E'. Once again, (like all Pixar features) it is technically brilliant, and wearing my strategic futurist lenses, suggest that it is a story that is engaging and arguably informative. But I wondered if somewhere along the way the apparent message(s) behind the film misses the mark?

With homage to HAL from the Clark/Kubrik '2001: A Space Odyessy', deliberate showing of the original Sputnik satellite as a human laden rocket ship blasts its way through space junk scattered around the planet, glimpses of the 'supersize' me mindset exposed in Sportlock's film, a nod to the powerpoint documentary 'An Inconvenient Truth' and others like Wall Street ('greed is good') there's no doubt that this is a film with a story to tell.

But will we get it?  Where other Pixar films have successfully negotiated delivering a film with simultaneous double lives pleasing both children and adults alike (strangers are not dangerous and change is fine (Toy Story); laughter is better than anger (Monsters Inc); you can't protect your loved ones by shutting the rest of the 'world out there' out (Finding Nemo) and others) Wall E doesn't blend quite as effectively.

So here's the story for the kids - a small robotic machine compactor with big eyes (think ET) is all alone and finds a friend to play with.  The friend is a bit hard to get to know but with persistence on Wall E's part, that friendship eventually blossoms.  Key message - work at being friends (I guess especially if you are lonely).  For the adults the story line is a bit more straightforward - we are a fat, gluttonous, lazy and selfish species who are more than willing to destroy the planet due to our desire to have more stuff.  But eventually we will see our way through the smokescreen and choose to be a positive contributor to the planet. That is what I took away at least :-)

As a futurist I find the adult message compelling if a tad hokey.  As an adult though I kept flicking in and out of narratives - is this essentially a feel good story, a love story, an environmental story or a story about greed?  I also wasn't sure if the film was taking a deliberate swipe at the industry of consumption (of which film making Hollywood style is both a great beneficiary and purveyor) or whether it was just using the ongoing downgrading of the planet as less suitable for humans to survive, as a simple back story to a 'search for love' film.

What interests me most is that this film could well be the first film from a mainstream 'messager' that considers the notion of 'enoughness'.  Most of you will know that this is a topic I've been tracking for about 6 years when I first started seeing the signs of a shift away from consuumption driven behaviour, and here we have a film that suggests a final destination for that mode of thinking - skyscrapers made out of trash. That such a mode of thinking is yet another step in the journey of homo sapiens sapiens might be arguable.

In current economic circumstances (for the rich nations experiencing a sub-shock) it would be too easy to link waste creation to economic ruin.  I won't do that here and do suggest Wall E is a film worth seeing at some point.  I just hope that the skyscrapers of trash message makes a link to the mainstream (western mode) of consuming at all costs for most of the audience.

 


See more events...

Keep informed - Sign up

Look ahead for your business - sign up for your exclusive updates.
name

email address

Events

When it comes to decision making 'Bias' can be friend or foe
Sunday 20 May 2018
McKinsey's interview with Richard Thaler on 'debiasing the corporation' is a really good one. I've spent the best part of two decades trying to help organisations unpack their biases through the use of foresight. I recommend this article to you
Read more...
Disaster Ahead for the People of Ipswich
Monday 23 April 2018
As the Ipswich Council has determined that recycling schemes are too expensive and indicates it will end collections, the question is 'what happens next'? If result of the explosion in Tip fees by Councils around Australia is anything to go by, what happens next will not be good
Read more...
Using Foresight Thinking to Enhance the Productivity of Nations
Friday 9 March 2018
As Nations look to develop their understanding of Productivity and more effective planning, National Productivity Councils are often the first point of call for Governments looking for ideas. The Asia Productivity Organisation has been running since 1961 helping its member countries develop more effective approaches. I've just spent a week in Tokyo helping a group of them think about the future
Read more...